{
 "title": "What people say about personal agents: dataset behind browser-use.com/posts/personal-ai-agent-browser",
 "collected_on": "2026-11-15 to 2026-11-16",
 "headline": {
  "unique_relevant_items": 33976,
  "statement": "33,976 unique public posts, comments, App Store reviews and GitHub issues about 12 personal agents.",
  "agent_item_pairs": 34529,
  "why_two_numbers": "34,529 counts each item once per agent it is about (this is the sum of the per-agent 'relevant' counts). 45 Reddit posts in the OpenClaw and Hermes sweeps were captured twice (as a post and as the root of their comment tree), 467 items are about two or more agents (for example OpenClaw vs Hermes threads, or ChatGPT dots in both OpenAI sweeps), which adds 508 extra agent-item pairs. 34,529 - 45 - 508 = 33,976 unique items.",
  "unique_by_source": {
   "appstore": 2368,
   "github": 4256,
   "hn": 10163,
   "reddit": 8664,
   "x": 8525
  },
  "collected_including_excluded": 46032,
  "hand_reviewed_total": 2737
 },
 "files": {
  "posts.csv": "One row per collected item per agent, relevant or not. Columns: agent, source, date (UTC, YYYY-MM-DD), url, appstore_review_id, relevant, basis. No post text and no author names. X links use x.com/i/status/<id>. App Store reviews have no per-review URL, so the row carries the app's review page plus the review id from Apple's public review feed."
 },
 "columns": {
  "relevant": "yes = counted; no = judged not about the agent (name collisions such as 'gut instinct', Pokemon, Linux tasklets, referral spam); unconfirmed = matched a search but the captured text did not show the product, excluded; vendor = posted by the agent's company or its staff, excluded.",
  "basis": "Why a relevant item counts: names_product = the product name or handle is in the captured text, quote or card; thread_or_subreddit_context = a reply or comment inside a thread or subreddit about the product, without naming it; app_review = review of the product's own App Store app; product_repo_issue = issue in the product's GitHub repo; hand_checked = a person read it and confirmed it."
 },
 "method": [
  "Sources: X (logged-in search in a cloud browser: phrase queries, date slices, Top tab, and reply trees of large threads), Reddit (JSON, pullpush archive or HTML search depending on what was reachable), Hacker News (Algolia API, stories and comments), GitHub issues (product repos, title keyword search), App Store (Apple's public customer-review RSS feed, US unless noted).",
  "Dedup within an agent by source id: X status id, Reddit post or comment id, HN objectID, GitHub issue number, App Store review id.",
  "Relevance: an item counts when it names the product (with agent context for ambiguous names), sits in a product thread or subreddit, or is a review of the product's app. Vendor and staff accounts are excluded.",
  "Themes (logins, blocks, payments, wrong actions and so on) were coded on a hand-read subset per agent plus keyword rules; see theme_coding per agent. Theme counts overlap and are not additive.",
  "X view counts are what X displayed at capture time (K/M rounding) and are a floor, not unique reach."
 ],
 "caveats": [
  "Not a random sample. Queries include complaint and praise words, so sentiment shares are biased toward strong opinions.",
  "Volume per agent reflects how reachable each source was, not only how popular the agent is: Reddit after 2026-10-13 is missing for Meta Muse and the OpenAI agent line (Reddit blocked the archive and cloud IPs); several X date slices failed on rate limits.",
  "The GitHub issue searches for OpenClaw, Hermes and Claude in Chrome used browser keywords, so those counts lean toward browser problems by design.",
  "Windows differ by agent (see window). Self-hosted agents (OpenClaw, Hermes) are covered since launch; hosted agents mostly from 2026-05-15 or their launch.",
  "Items whose basis is thread_or_subreddit_context do not name the product themselves. Filter on basis = names_product, app_review, product_repo_issue or hand_checked for a stricter count.",
  "Keyword-only theme tags have about 70% precision on informal spot checks."
 ],
 "agents": [
  {
   "agent": "openclaw",
   "label": "OpenClaw",
   "research_label": "OpenClaw (earlier names Clawdbot, Moltbot; name regex includes clawd/clawdbot/moltbot)",
   "window": "since launch; relevant items dated 2026-01-04 to 2026-11-15. Gap: Nov-Dec 2025 Clawdbot-era posts barely present (earliest relevant item 2026-01-04).",
   "collected": 12254,
   "relevant": 10201,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 10177,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "github": 2349,
    "hn": 6637,
    "reddit": 592,
    "x": 623
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "names_product": 4843,
    "product_repo_issue": 2349,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 3009
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-01-04",
    "2026-11-15"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-01": 1056,
    "2026-02": 3338,
    "2026-03": 1388,
    "2026-04": 1426,
    "2026-05": 536,
    "2026-06": 539,
    "2026-07": 358,
    "2026-08": 385,
    "2026-09": 508,
    "2026-10": 427,
    "2026-11": 240
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 1828,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 0,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 225
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 261,
   "theme_coding": "Complaint/praise themes: 261 items hand-read (X 156, HN 70, Reddit comments 35) plus GitHub bug-issue title keyword hits. Keyword tags on the other non-GitHub items are kept as unverified and not used for theme counts.",
   "method": "12,254 unique items after dedup (X by status id, Reddit by post/comment id, HN by objectID, GitHub by issue number): X 788 (logged-in search, 16 phrase queries + 7 monthly date slices Apr-Nov 2026, top tab, plus reply trees of top posts), HN 8,327 (Algolia stories+comments, targeted phrases, full threads), Reddit 146 posts + 500 comments, GitHub openclaw/openclaw 2,493 issues (title keyword search: browser, chrome, cdp, relay, extension, login, cookie, captcha, cloudflare, playwright etc, so GitHub is browser-skewed by design). Relevant after name/vendor filter: 10,201 (X 623 excl. vendor/maintainer accounts, HN 6,637, Reddit 92+500, GitHub 2,349). Manually coded (read by agent): 261 (X 156, HN 70, Reddit comments 35); 198 carry a complaint, 75 praise, 55 browser-related. Theme count = manual + GitHub bug-issue title hits; count_regex_unverified (keyword tags on 7,852 non-GitHub relevant items) is reported only in the raw/summary file, not trusted. Sum of displayed X views on relevant posts = 151.2M (includes posts that also mention Hermes). Not covered: App Store (no official app), Discord, Nov-Dec 2025 X. Summary with per-theme manual/github/regex split: /home/exedev/Documents/browser-use/funnels/personal-agents-2026-11-15/sweeps/openclawhermes_summary.json"
  },
  {
   "agent": "hermes",
   "label": "Hermes Agent",
   "research_label": "Hermes Agent (Nous Research)",
   "window": "since launch; relevant items dated 2026-02-26 to 2026-11-15",
   "collected": 3390,
   "relevant": 3112,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 3091,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "github": 1025,
    "hn": 337,
    "reddit": 1361,
    "x": 389
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "names_product": 1525,
    "product_repo_issue": 1025,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 562
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-02-26",
    "2026-11-15"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-02": 10,
    "2026-03": 84,
    "2026-04": 307,
    "2026-05": 325,
    "2026-06": 496,
    "2026-07": 362,
    "2026-08": 360,
    "2026-09": 353,
    "2026-10": 459,
    "2026-11": 353
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 161,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 0,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 117
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 191,
   "theme_coding": "Complaint/praise themes: 191 items hand-read (X 80, Reddit posts 71, Reddit comments 37, HN 3) plus GitHub bug-issue title keyword hits. Keyword-only tags are not used for theme counts.",
   "method": "3,390 unique items after dedup (same keys as OpenClaw): X 571 (logged-in search, 16 phrase queries + 9 monthly date slices Mar-Nov 2026; the Aug, Sep, Oct-Nov slices failed in the killed run and were re-run on 2026-11-16, 15/17/15 posts), Reddit 786 posts (mostly r/hermesagent) + 648 comments, HN 360, GitHub NousResearch/hermes-agent 1,025 issues (title keyword search on browser terms: browser, chrome, cdp, playwright, camofox, browserbase, browser_use, captcha, cloudflare, cookie, login, stealth, bot-detection, so browser-skewed by design). Relevant: 3,112 (X 389 excl. vendor accounts, Reddit 713+648, HN 337, GitHub 1,025). Manually coded: 191 (X 80, Reddit posts 71, Reddit comments 37, HN 3); 113 complaint, 82 praise, only 13 browser-related. Theme count = manual + GitHub bug-issue title hits; regex-only counts kept in summary file as unverified. X views sum 24.6M includes posts that also mention OpenClaw. Not covered: Discord, App Store reviews for the mobile beta (launched ~Nov 2026, too new). Summary: /home/exedev/Documents/browser-use/funnels/personal-agents-2026-11-15/sweeps/openclawhermes_summary.json"
  },
  {
   "agent": "instinct",
   "label": "Instinct",
   "research_label": "Instinct",
   "window": "2026-09-01 to 2026-11-15 (follow-up to our Aug 13 - Sep 1 report)",
   "collected": 2749,
   "relevant": 2291,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 2291,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "hn": 52,
    "reddit": 226,
    "x": 2013
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "names_product": 2084,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 207
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-09-01",
    "2026-11-15"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-09": 437,
    "2026-10": 886,
    "2026-11": 968
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 197,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 261,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 0
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 653,
   "theme_coding": "653 items hand-reviewed, including all 258 complaint-tagged items. Praise tags on unreviewed items come from keyword rules (about 70% precision on a 10-item spot check).",
   "method": "instinct.json has 2,749 rows deduped by source+id (X status id, Reddit t3/t1 id, HN objectID). 2,291 are relevant: X 2,013, Reddit 226, HN 52. 197 were marked irrelevant (AMD/Garmin/'gut instinct' noise, or replies in the multi-product Tim Ferriss thread that don't name Instinct). 261 X rows are relevance-unknown (they matched the query but the captured text doesn't show the product) and are excluded. X method: logged-in search on a cloud browser. 19 four-day date slices plus phrase queries (complaint words: broken, blocked, captcha, login, banned, slow, expensive, privacy, scam, refund, doesn't work, stopped working, paywall, OTP, rate limit; praise words: love, insane, magic, finally, amazing, wow, game changer), plus 5 opened reply trees (Resy ban, Tim Ferriss 'favorite assistant', WhatsApp ban, OTP, deedydas EU261). That is 27 query files and 3,137 raw captures. 157 of the relevant X items are context-only replies inside Instinct threads. The views floor is the sum of displayed X view counts on 2,012 relevant X posts, snapshot Nov 15-16, at X's K/M precision. It is not unique reach. 653 items were manually reviewed. Every one of the 258 complaint-tagged items was hand-checked. Praise tags on items nobody reviewed come from regex, and a 10-item spot check on the Poke set found about 70% precision. Theme counts overlap and do not add up. Reddit came from r/InstinctHQ and r/instinctai RSS in the earlier run, because Reddit's search API was blocked. HN came from the Algolia API. GAPS: there is no App Store app (Instinct is iMessage/WhatsApp/SMS only). GitHub issues weren't swept (OpenInstinct is a third-party clone). Some slices hit X 'Something went wrong' rate limits and needed retries, so X search is not a firehose. COMPARISON with the Aug 13 - Sep 1 report (864 posts, 21.51M views in 19 days): this window has more posts but much less reach per post (2,013 X posts, 8.84M views in 76 days). Volume is still rising: 437 relevant items in September, 886 in October, 968 in Nov 1-15. In the earlier window the loudest objection was the email/permissions trust boundary (134 posts, 1.88M views), and operational failures were small (0.44M). Here, privacy has dropped to 30 items and 104K views. The top complaints are now platform and site friction. Sites enforced against agent behavior (the Resy account ban, 616K views; JPM, Citi, BofA and RBC blocking agents). WhatsApp banned users and Instinct's WhatsApp channel went down on Nov 1 (27 platform-risk items; 16 account-ban items with 769K views). OTP/login friction drew 24 items (375K views). Invite/waitlist requests drew 44. Valuation skepticism ($10B, then $30B) drew 15. Praise shifted toward money outcomes (the EU261 refund, Link balance budgets) and multi-agent coordination."
  },
  {
   "agent": "poke",
   "label": "Poke",
   "research_label": "Poke (The Interaction Company, poke.com; acquired by Cognition, announced 2026-07-23)",
   "window": "2026-05-15 to 2026-11-15 (last 6 months)",
   "collected": 2038,
   "relevant": 1764,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 1764,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "hn": 12,
    "reddit": 35,
    "x": 1717
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "names_product": 1501,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 263
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-05-15",
    "2026-11-15"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-05": 41,
    "2026-06": 635,
    "2026-07": 541,
    "2026-08": 208,
    "2026-09": 196,
    "2026-10": 83,
    "2026-11": 60
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 55,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 219,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 0
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 633,
   "theme_coding": "633 items hand-reviewed, including every complaint-tagged and browser-related item (189 complaint items). Remaining tags from keyword rules.",
   "method": "poke.json has 2,038 rows deduped by source+id. 1,764 are relevant: X 1,717, Reddit 35, HN 12. 55 are irrelevant (Pokemon, poke bowls, unrelated) and 219 X rows are relevance-unknown and excluded. X method: logged-in search on a cloud browser. 13 two-week date slices May 15 - Nov 16, 2 one-week re-slices, 3 complaint-phrase queries, 1 praise-phrase query and 1 Top query, all on (@interaction OR 'poke ai' OR 'poke imessage' OR 'poke agent' OR 'poke.com' OR 'interaction company' OR 'texted/asked/using poke' OR 'poke app'). Plus 5 opened reply trees: the Jun 4 Apple Messages launch, ricoberan 'naive intern', JoshuaIPark $199 Ultra, bukovinafilip post-acquisition 'downfall', and the Jul 4 Poke Human promo. That is 24 query files and 2,259 raw captures. 247 relevant X items are context-only replies inside those threads. The views floor of 15.35M includes Interaction's own launch posts (the Jun 4 launch at 5.04M and the Cognition announcement at 2.43M carry about half of it). 633 items were manually reviewed, including every complaint-tagged and browser-related item (189 complaint items). Reddit had no search JSON (blocked), so it came from logged-out browser HTML search: 9 queries plus r/PokeAssistant new/top, 256 raw posts. After filtering to window and relevance, that left 13 posts plus 22 comments from 4 opened threads. HN: Algolia (Apple approval, Cognition acquisition, comparison threads). Monthly relevant volume: Jun 635 (inflated by the launch reply tree), Jul 541, Aug 208, Sep 196, Oct 83, Nov 1-15 60. Conversation fell sharply after the acquisition, and Poke got 0 mentions in the 212-reply Oct 23 Tim Ferriss 'favorite personal agent' thread. GAPS: the X Jul 17-24 slice failed twice (page evaluate timeout), so it is covered only by the phrase and top queries. The May 29 - Jun 12 slice returned only 20 items (likely truncated by rate limits). The loose 'poke + complaint word' query was skipped as noisy. There is no App Store app (Poke runs on iMessage/SMS/WhatsApp/Telegram). GitHub: 64 issues/PRs mention 'poke.com' since May 15, but all are third-party MCP/recipe integrations with 0 end-user complaints, so they are excluded. Praise tags on unreviewed items are regex-based (about 70% precision on a 10-item spot check)."
  },
  {
   "agent": "meta-muse",
   "label": "Meta Muse",
   "research_label": "Meta Muse (Meta AI personal agent; incl. Muse Mac app, Chrome plug-in, Wallet-style checkout via PayPal/Stripe Link)",
   "window": "2026-09-08 (launch) to 2026-11-16",
   "collected": 7629,
   "relevant": 7021,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 7021,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "appstore": 977,
    "hn": 2161,
    "reddit": 3073,
    "x": 810
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "app_review": 977,
    "hand_checked": 227,
    "names_product": 1766,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 4051
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-09-08",
    "2026-11-16"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-09": 2705,
    "2026-10": 3380,
    "2026-11": 936
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 409,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 199,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 0
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 324,
   "theme_coding": "Theme counts are hand labels on 324 items (X 165, App Store 97, HN 31, Reddit 31). Keyword counts over all relevant items are reported for scale only.",
   "method": "FACTS: 7,629 deduped rows (dedup key = X status id / reddit t1|t3 id / HN objectID / App Store review id); 7,021 relevant, 408 excluded as referral/1B-token spam, 199 X rows unconfirmed (product not visible in captured text). Relevant by source: X 810 (521 search-matched + 289 reply-tree-only from 5 threads incl. the launch post), Reddit 3,073 (pullpush, 2026-09-09..2026-10-13 only), HN 2,161 (Algolia + all comments in Muse launch thread 49615537), App Store US 977 reviews (2026-09-08..11-14; 857 five-star, 52 one-star). X: 1,182 raw captures from 16 query/thread files (logged-in X, phrase groups x complaint/praise/browser words, live+top, official @Muse, 2 of 10 weekly slices; other slices not run because X returned 'Something went wrong' rate limits). MANUAL REVIEW: 324 items hand-labeled (X 165, App Store 97, HN 31, Reddit 31); theme counts below are hand-labeled counts out of those 324. Regex counts over all 7,021 relevant (noisy, for scale only): privacy 394, reliability 376, login 182, blocked/captcha 145, payment 143. App Store 4-5 star regex (n=893): love 577, wow 142, proactive/reminders 113, delegation 56, free 49. GAPS: Reddit after 2026-10-13 missing (reddit.com blocks cloud browser IPs, old.reddit now requires login); only 31/3,073 Reddit and 31/2,161 HN items hand-reviewed; X views are a floor (displayed counts at capture). BROWSER FACTS seen in posts (cite in file): each Muse runs in its own VM (2 CPU/8GB per @HedgeyeComm), inline browser you can watch/take over (HN 49619507, @testingcatalog), Amazon blocked Muse Sep 20-21 saying it did not identify itself (@galratner), United + eBay blocked agents Nov 11-13, HUMAN Security: Muse ~59-60% of agent requests in Oct, ~half unsigned per DataDome (@AIScanSite), POPPY/Personal Agent Protocol launched Nov 13 to avoid bot blocks, 1Password approve-then-fill login (@androidcentral), Stripe Link virtual cards + PayPal checkout."
  },
  {
   "agent": "openai-agent",
   "label": "ChatGPT agent mode / Atlas / Work / dots (OpenAI agent line)",
   "research_label": "ChatGPT agent / ChatGPT Atlas agent mode (successors: ChatGPT Work Jul 9, Atlas shut Aug 9, Dots Sep 29, ChatGPT Wallet Nov 13)",
   "window": "2026-05-15 to 2026-11-16",
   "collected": 3125,
   "relevant": 2765,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 2765,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "appstore": 16,
    "hn": 735,
    "reddit": 1183,
    "x": 831
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "app_review": 16,
    "hand_checked": 237,
    "names_product": 1258,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 1254
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-05-15",
    "2026-11-16"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-05": 135,
    "2026-06": 196,
    "2026-07": 658,
    "2026-08": 197,
    "2026-09": 866,
    "2026-10": 234,
    "2026-11": 479
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 28,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 332,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 0
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 245,
   "theme_coding": "Theme counts are hand labels on 245 items (X 118, Reddit 94, HN 25, App Store 8). Keyword counts over all relevant items are for scale only.",
   "method": "FACTS: 3,125 deduped rows; 2,765 relevant; 28 excluded off-topic (MongoDB Atlas, Copilot/Cursor agent mode, etc.), 332 X rows unconfirmed. Relevant by source: X 831 (481 search-matched + 350 reply-tree-only from 4 threads: Dots launch, Wallet launch, ChatGPT Work launch, @robinebers), Reddit 1,183 (pullpush, 2026-05-15..2026-10-13; r/ChatGPTAtlas full + 'ChatGPT agent'/'agent mode'/'ChatGPT Atlas'/'Atlas browser' queries), HN 735 (Algolia + full Dots launch thread 49896604, 646 comments), App Store 16 (ChatGPT iOS reviews mentioning dot/agent, out of 3,833 fetched). X: 1,427 raw captures, 19 query files. First X query run (with a bare 'Operator' clause) was noisy and moved to openai-agent_raw/x_noisy_operator_query, not counted. Because the 'ChatGPT agent' product was renamed/absorbed (ChatGPT Work, then Dots), Dots/Wallet queries were added; this OVERLAPS any separate 'Dot' sweep. MANUAL REVIEW: 245 items hand-labeled (X 118, Reddit 94, HN 25, App Store 8); counts below are out of those 245. Regex over all 2,765 relevant: reliability 238, pricing 180, payment 159, shutdown 105, privacy 97. GAPS: Reddit after 2026-10-13; Atlas had no App Store presence; only 1 of 6 monthly X slices and 0 of 6 complaint slices ran (X rate limits). Views floor 24.2M incl. official @OpenAI/@ChatGPT posts, 7.16M excluding official accounts. BROWSER FACTS: agent mode runs in a cloud VM and keeps screenshots 90 days (r/TrustRacer 1uee107); ChatGPT Work signs into sites 'without ChatGPT ever seeing your username or password' (https://x.com/ChatGPT/status/2092366554965107164); cloud browser 'used to die at every sign-in wall, now pauses and hands YOU' the login (https://x.com/JulianGoldieSEO/status/2081701636779761803); one-click import of Chrome/Atlas passwords into in-app browser; built-in browser supports Chrome extensions (Sep 18); Dots cloud env MITMs TLS with OpenAI-issued certs (HN 49905400); Wallet = network token + Face ID per purchase, US Pro only; merchants told to allow signed agent browser requests in CDN/WAF; Dots launch post touted +80% better captcha solving."
  },
  {
   "agent": "manus",
   "label": "Manus",
   "research_label": "Manus (agent + Browser Operator; Manus 2.0, Cue, Studio)",
   "window": "2026-05-15 to 2026-11-16",
   "collected": 3978,
   "relevant": 3118,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 3118,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "appstore": 602,
    "hn": 126,
    "reddit": 1681,
    "x": 709
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "app_review": 602,
    "hand_checked": 191,
    "names_product": 2016,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 309
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-05-15",
    "2026-11-16"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-05": 451,
    "2026-06": 660,
    "2026-07": 459,
    "2026-08": 582,
    "2026-09": 620,
    "2026-10": 256,
    "2026-11": 90
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 608,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 252,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 0
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 430,
   "theme_coding": "Theme counts are hand labels on 430 items (all 239 App Store reviews rated 1-3 stars in window, X 106, Reddit 77, HN 8).",
   "method": "FACTS: 3,978 deduped rows; 3,118 relevant; 593 excluded as referral/free-credit spam ('Join Manus now and claim free credits', invite links), ~15 off-topic (Manus Island etc.), 252 X unconfirmed. Relevant by source: X 709 (337 search-matched + 372 reply-tree-only from Manus 2.0 launch, 'Note to our users' independence post, independence day post, Cue launch), Reddit 1,681 (pullpush 2026-05-15..2026-10-13 incl. r/manusai; plus title-only reddit search units from prior run through 2026-11-15), HN 126, App Store 602 reviews (us 395, de 49, ca 46, gb 43, au 42...; 308 five-star, 195 one-star). X: 1,261 raw captures, 15 query files (1 of 6 monthly slices ran). MANUAL REVIEW: 430 items hand-labeled (App Store 239 = all 1-3 star reviews in window, X 106, Reddit 77, HN 8); counts below are out of those 430. Regex over 3,118 relevant: pricing/credits 1,047 (query-biased: 'manus credits' was a search term), reliability 405, refunds 178, support 148. CAVEATS: several high-view anti-Manus posts are competitor promos (AllyHub, CREAO); Manus browser-specific complaints are rare (2 captcha/Cloudflare items) because users mostly use it for building sites/slides/research, not logged-in web chores. Context: Meta's ~$2B acquisition (Dec 2025) blocked by China; Meta unwound it, Manus independent Sep 1, 2026; Aug 23-26 data migration/account deletion wave; free access to Manus 1.6 until Aug 25; Manus 2.0 + Cue launched Sep 28; free chat mode removed Oct. Views floor 17.4M incl. @ManusAI, 1.97M excl. official."
  },
  {
   "agent": "grok-bot",
   "label": "Grok Bot",
   "research_label": "Grok Bot (xAI)",
   "window": "X/HN/Reddit 2026-08-01..2026-11-16 (beta launched 2026-08-11); App Store = 500 most recent US reviews (2026-10-24..2026-11-16, not windowed)",
   "collected": 3048,
   "relevant": 1395,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 1395,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "appstore": 500,
    "hn": 232,
    "reddit": 263,
    "x": 400
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "app_review": 500,
    "names_product": 651,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 244
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-07-09",
    "2026-11-16"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-07": 1,
    "2026-08": 197,
    "2026-09": 113,
    "2026-10": 304,
    "2026-11": 780
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 1621,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 0,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 32
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 0,
   "theme_coding": "Keyword rules with complaint phrasing, attribution limited to +-250 characters of the product name. Informal spot-check precision about 70%. No full hand review.",
   "method": "1,395 unique relevant non-vendor items, deduped by id per source. X: 732 raw captures from 8 query files (complaint phrases, praise phrases, context-phrase query, 4 of 7 planned 2-week lang:en slices, 1 reply thread) -> 709 unique status ids -> 400 relevant non-vendor (277 dropped: 'grok bot' used for the @grok reply bot or no agent context, or phrase hidden in a truncated long post; 32 vendor posts from @bot/@xai excluded). HN Algolia: 1,456 hits -> 232 relevant. App Store (id6794501026, 24,041 ratings): 500 reviews, all kept (1-star 53, 5-star 407). Reddit (cloud browser HTML, JSON is blocked): 383 -> 263 relevant (r/GrokBot new + 'grok bot' search + 10 top threads). Missing: grok-bot 'Top' search (crashed the cloud browser twice), 3 pruned slices (X rate limits), Reddit search posts seen only as titles. Tags are regex keyword rules with complaint phrasing, attribution limited to +-250 chars of the product name in multi-product posts; informal spot-check precision ~70%. Item counts: 263 with a complaint theme, 573 with a praise theme, 111 browser-related, 39 browser-related complaints."
  },
  {
   "agent": "dot",
   "label": "ChatGPT dots",
   "research_label": "ChatGPT dots (OpenAI; our benchmark 'Dot' label)",
   "window": "2026-09-20..2026-11-16 (dots launched DevDay 2026-09-29); HN/Reddit 2026-05-15..2026-11-16",
   "collected": 3520,
   "relevant": 800,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 800,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "hn": 75,
    "reddit": 47,
    "x": 678
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "names_product": 594,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 206
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-07-20",
    "2026-11-16"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-07": 4,
    "2026-09": 37,
    "2026-10": 188,
    "2026-11": 571
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 2720,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 0,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 0
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 0,
   "theme_coding": "Keyword rules, informal spot-check precision about 70%. No full hand review.",
   "method": "800 unique relevant non-vendor items. X: 983 raw captures from 8 query files (complaint phrases, praise phrases, '\"my dot\" chatgpt/openai' query, 2 of 4 planned weekly slices, Top, 2 reply threads) -> 888 unique -> 678 relevant (210 dropped: no dots/openai context, or truncated long posts). Note 179 captures come from one feature-request reply thread (JustinBleuel), which inflates 'wrong_action' and 'love' counts. HN: 2,270 hits ('dots' is noisy) -> 75 relevant. Reddit: 362 -> 47. No App Store source (dots lives inside the ChatGPT app). Benchmark 'Dot' = OpenAI browser runner relabelled, so this sweep is about the consumer product ChatGPT dots. Regex tags, informal precision ~70%. 152 items with complaint, 131 praise, 80 browser-related, 28 browser-related complaints."
  },
  {
   "agent": "comet",
   "label": "Perplexity Comet",
   "research_label": "Perplexity Comet (Comet Assistant / agentic browser)",
   "window": "X/HN/Reddit 2026-05-15..2026-11-16; App Store = all 272 reviews the RSS feed returns (2026-03-18 onward, not windowed)",
   "collected": 1589,
   "relevant": 627,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 627,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "appstore": 272,
    "hn": 7,
    "reddit": 201,
    "x": 147
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "app_review": 272,
    "names_product": 305,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 50
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-03-18",
    "2026-11-16"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-03": 158,
    "2026-04": 39,
    "2026-05": 43,
    "2026-06": 48,
    "2026-07": 58,
    "2026-08": 119,
    "2026-09": 52,
    "2026-10": 37,
    "2026-11": 73
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 962,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 0,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 0
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 0,
   "theme_coding": "Keyword rules, informal spot-check precision about 70%. No full hand review.",
   "method": "627 unique relevant non-vendor items. X: 284 raw captures from 7 query files (complaint, praise, 3 of 6 monthly lang:en slices, Top, 1 thread) -> 229 unique -> 147 relevant (82 dropped, mostly long posts where the phrase was truncated). HN: 739 hits -> 7 relevant (Comet barely discussed on HN in window). App Store (id6748622471, 7,845 ratings): 272 reviews (1-star 44, 5-star 158). Reddit: 349 (r/PerplexityComet new, r/perplexity_ai 'comet' search, phrase searches, 10 threads) -> 201. A first noisy Reddit pass is kept as longtail_raw_reddit/comet_v1_noisy.json and excluded. Low X volume is itself a signal: Comet chatter on X is small vs Grok Bot/dots. Regex tags, ~70% precision. 155 complaint, 227 praise, 354 browser-related, 103 browser-related complaints."
  },
  {
   "agent": "claude-chrome",
   "label": "Claude in Chrome",
   "research_label": "Claude in Chrome (Anthropic extension)",
   "window": "2026-05-15..2026-11-16",
   "collected": 2221,
   "relevant": 1271,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 1271,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "github": 882,
    "hn": 59,
    "reddit": 49,
    "x": 281
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "names_product": 327,
    "product_repo_issue": 882,
    "thread_or_subreddit_context": 62
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-05-15",
    "2026-11-16"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-05": 63,
    "2026-06": 98,
    "2026-07": 205,
    "2026-08": 277,
    "2026-09": 233,
    "2026-10": 157,
    "2026-11": 238
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 949,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 0,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 1
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 0,
   "theme_coding": "Keyword rules, informal spot-check precision about 70%; GitHub issues tagged on title only. No full hand review.",
   "method": "1,271 unique relevant non-vendor items. GitHub dominates: anthropics/claude-code issues matching \"claude in chrome\" created since 2026-05-15 = 1,227 total; fetched top 1,000 by best match -> 882 contain the phrase. GitHub issues are tagged on TITLE only (templates add boilerplate) and are bug/feature reports, so this product's complaint share is structurally inflated vs others. X: 516 raw captures from 7 query files (complaint, praise, 3 of 6 monthly slices, 2 threads; Top search failed on rate limit) -> 450 unique -> 281 relevant (168 dropped, mostly truncated long posts). HN: 318 -> 59. Reddit: 453 -> 49 (strict thread inheritance). Regex tags, ~70% precision. 950 complaint, 74 praise, 687 browser-related, 534 browser-related complaints."
  },
  {
   "agent": "tasklet",
   "label": "Tasklet",
   "research_label": "Tasklet (Shortwave)",
   "window": "2026-05-15..2026-11-16",
   "collected": 491,
   "relevant": 164,
   "relevant_unique_within_agent": 164,
   "relevant_by_source": {
    "appstore": 1,
    "hn": 13,
    "reddit": 17,
    "x": 133
   },
   "relevant_by_basis": {
    "app_review": 1,
    "names_product": 163
   },
   "relevant_date_range": [
    "2026-05-22",
    "2026-11-16"
   ],
   "relevant_by_month": {
    "2026-05": 3,
    "2026-06": 28,
    "2026-07": 13,
    "2026-08": 28,
    "2026-09": 10,
    "2026-10": 32,
    "2026-11": 50
   },
   "excluded": {
    "not_relevant": 187,
    "relevance_unconfirmed": 0,
    "vendor_or_official_account": 140
   },
   "hand_reviewed": 0,
   "theme_coding": "Keyword rules, informal spot-check precision about 70%. No full hand review.",
   "method": "164 unique relevant non-vendor items (below the 40+ complaint target: real complaint volume is tiny). X: 354 raw captures from 6 query files (complaint, praise, Top, 3 of 6 monthly slices) -> 290 unique -> 133 relevant non-vendor; 140 vendor posts (@TaskletAI, CEO @startupandrew, @MichaelLatman, Shortwave) excluded, i.e. nearly half of Tasklet's X volume is the company itself; 17 dropped (Linux kernel 'tasklet' noise). HN: 63 -> 13. App Store (Tasklet AI, id6806454524, launched 2026-10-29): 1 review (5 stars) of 30 ratings. Reddit: 137 -> 17 (most search hits did not name Tasklet in visible text). Only 12 items carry a complaint theme, 1 browser-related complaint; 36 carry praise. Much X chatter is YC Demo Day revenue buzz ($5M ARR / $7M run rate), not product use."
  }
 ]
}